Post ep talk: 308 MCKAY AND MRS. MILLER *spoilers*

[Hawkeye]

Post ep talk: 308 MCKAY AND MRS. MILLER *spoilers*

Welcome to this week post episode talk of the show Stargate Atlantis, please be aware that if you haven’t watched this episode yet, that the following post below may contain Major Plot Spoilers which might ruin it for you. Don’t say that we didn’t warn you….

Enjoy…..

Right to improve the Post episode reviews here, I am redesigning the rating system to give a broader idea of what you thought of the show. These Past few episode have been given very poor reviews by you guys, the point of a post episode talk is to re-view it by breaking in up and discussing with other on how you thought the story line.

The rating system will now be as follows a 5 Chevron rating… 1 being a very poor rating of the episode and 5 being an excellent rating of the episodes.

Please rate the following areas…

Story Line
What you thought of the current episodes story line, was it action packed? Was it thrilling? That it had you sitting on the edge of your chair as you watched the story unfold? Did it connect well with the shows larger Story arc?

Charter Development
From the Regulars to the not so regulars of the show, what were you taking on both the character and the actor? Did they portray the character in the right light or were they really bad…

Special Effect’s
A very important of every science-fiction show is the quality of special effects. This can range from the Alien life forms that the SGC or SGA teams encounter on these missions. To the technology of ships to little pocket devices they uses.

[ZipCrash]

Decent episodes, alot better than SG-1 has been that's for. I kept expecting Rod to turn out evil or have some other agenda as all the other SG-1 alternate universe episodes have gone (as far as I can remember) so it was good that he didn't. David can't green screen act as well as some of the SG-1/SGA actors. A few shots were too obvious but not too bad overall.

[Hawkeye]

Story Line
Overall a very intresting stand alone episode, it opened up a whole area of McKay we just never known about here. There was one of two issues I have a problem with, such as the double McKay not being effected by ENTROPIC CASCADE FAILURE like in Point of View, but they seemed to have also forggoten that while filming Ripple effect

Charter Development
we finally see a little of McKay and understand why he such a annoying hardass....

Special Effect’s
not much in the way of Special effect this week, but overall the story line makes up for it....

[River]

A good ep. Little of Ronan (always a plus)
Humor, not much tension, very little action.
So no ZPM... hups

7/10

[Hawkeye]

Yes but what about rodney full name? Dr. Meredith Rodney McKay

[ZipCrash]

Didn't we know that already? I seem to recall somebody telling somebody that Rodeny's middle name was meredith to "cheer them up" or was that SG-1?

[Hawkeye]

I don't remember it before...

[Kolyafan]

I do not remember hearing that either and I loved the whole episode so I give it a 10 out of 10

[ZipCrash]

I know it was on one of the stargates I'm seriously thinking SGA, maybe it was Ford? Or maybe it was SG-1 and Daniel or something? I know there was something like for somebody!! Wait now that I think about it, I think it was SG-1 and who found out that the middle intial wasn't just the letter but it stood for some girly name. The character said something like "atleast they didn't call me...." and whoever it was said "why would somebody..." wait that's not just a *insurt letter here*. Arg this bothering me, where are you fan thats remember everything when I need u!

[lord-denis]

it was an grat ep. 10/10 its just bad that we dont have the zpm anymore .

[Chey]

Good ep, all the Meredith stuff was great Good to see Jeanie too True, not enough action in I did think the Rod problem was too quickly fixed, but no biggie. No ZPM is a problem, but something will come up lol

7/10

[Asgard4ever]

Good ep and funny too (the two Mckays thing )
Meredith, oh my! He will be so humiliated!

8/10

[Daniel Jackson]

Hears my analysis in a nut shell...

Merideth....Funny
Rod...Not

[Chey]

:O What do you mean little of Ronan? I love him I wish there was more of him inthis ep

[seffy]

Another good ep. Personally, I'm glad we got Rodney and not Rod. A cool, leather jacketed and spiky haired McKay just wouldn't be the same. So much better to have the arrogant nerdy one we all know and love. Nice also to see Miss Hewlett making an appearance as McKay's sister. Talk about type-casting